This is the greatest headline of all time
by Hanlon on March 5, 2007 at 9:56 pmOkay, we have officially entered Orwellian-Land. I don’t really have anything to add except check this damn headline out: White House Privacy Panel OKs Controversial Surveillance Programs.
And it gets better still!
A White House privacy board has determined that two of the Bush administration’s controversial surveillance programs — electronic eavesdropping and financial tracking — do not violate citizens’ civil liberties.
After operating mostly in secret for a year, the five-member Privacy and Civil Liberties Board is preparing to release its first report to Congress next week.
You can’t make this stuff up, people. The Privacy and Civil Liberties Board. Now, strictly speaking, there’s an O in there for Observation, and in case you’re wondering what the PCLO board does here it is for you.
The Board will (1) examine the activities of the Department to ensure that it continues to fully protect the privacy and civil liberties of all Americans; (2) recommend policies, guidelines, and other administrative actions; and (3) refer credible information pertaining to possible privacy or civil liberties violations by any federal employee or official to the appropriate office for prompt investigation.
Okay, they’re making sure our privacy stays in tact. Good stuff. Is there a catch? Of course there is. Back to the original article.
The board does not have subpoena power, and the White House can check its annual reports to Congress. The members serve at the pleasure of Bush, and Attorney General Alberto Gonzales has final say over whether officials must comply with the board’s recommendations.
Okay, so the board can’t really do anything, the White House checks its reports, and Berty can say if any of their recommendations. Wait, what was number 2 in their purposes again?
2) recommend policies, guidelines, and other administrative actions
Right, recommending stuff. No actual POWER, but they sure can wave their arms and say “hey, why dontcha do this?” Not that I think they will. Once again, back to the article.
Bush appointed [Carol Dinkins, a Houston lawyer and former Reagan administration assistant attorney general], a Republican, to chair the board. A longtime friend of the Bush family, she was treasurer of Bush’s first campaign for governor of Texas, and she is a longtime partner in the law firm of Vinson & Elkins, where Gonzales was once a partner.
I’m not sure it’s possible to make this story any more ridiculous. My comments have been sparse here, because honestly there’s not much I can do to mock it or comment on the complete and utter idiocy. I mean… jeez.
Posted: March 5th, 2007 under lawmaking, spying.




Comment from JollyRoger
Time March 6, 2007 at 12:03 am
So “Electrode Al” will make sure the board does its job.
Wonderful. Kinda like having David Duke head up a Civil Rights Commission…